When we consider whether or not to implement a school uniform pot- icy, we need to understand the validity of each proponent's arguments. Every human being has a certain level of individuality and its loss can significantly injure a society. endstream
endobj
startxref
If we were able to give an hour to students in the morning, we would see an increase in their physical mentality, their academic skill level, and an overall happier lifestyle. Schools should start later because of academic benefits, health benefits, and the safety of students.
Individuality vs Conformity | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations While some people strive to be non-conformist, conformity is a fact of life for the vast majority of humankind. Not all kinds of conformity are the same. Gutting and Edmundson both blame the structure of the education system, but at the same time it sounds like the change needs to come only from students. From a political perspective, uniform detractors point to the right of individuals to free expression. As a student, I am often troubled by the rigid routines of the school day, despite the fact that I am actually a very habitual person. That is why Conroe High Schools principal, Dr. Weatherly, should change the schools schedule to have less, but longer, classes in a single day to create a less stressful environment for the students and teachers benefit. In the article title "Individuality vs. Conformity: The Healthy Middle?" by an anonymous high school student it says that there are only two thing that a typical high school student wants to typically achieve in their short high school life (par. Conformity denotes a wide-ranging phenomenon in which people (intentionally or unintentionally) shift their behavior or beliefs to fit in with a larger group. This type of outlook is what gives conformity a bad wrap. 2 Pages. Now, nearly two decades later, 19 percent of public schools across the country require uniforms, while 57 percent enforce a strict dress code. One classic example is the nature vs nurture debate; it tries to verify whether genes or the environment is more powerful in dictating the consistencies of our behavior. Toll free 1(888)814-4206 1(888)499-5521. On the other side, some professors try to force students into a nine hour school day. Countless schools across America start earlier than the recommended. However, if they taught in one of my classes that I actually have an interest in I might have a shot of being their perfect student they have conversations about on the. Students who do wish to be successful by American standards and want to attend college are exposed to perhaps the biggest reason American schools enforce a sense of conformity and make classes and curriculum mandatory: standardized testing, such as the SAT and ACT. Regardless of how old we are, we never stop learning. Individualism on the other hand is being one with one's self; one can wacka, nerdy, athletic, or whatsoever andshow more content
Is Poor Body Image Caused by Peer Pressure? Countless students all over the US struggle to keep their eyes open throughout the day because school classes start too early in the morning. The actual author of this quote, however, is not important. In 2015, American students came in 24th in reading, 25th in science, and 41st in math out of 72 countriesnot the worst, but far from the best, (pg. For example, a foreign student adopted a new way of life; however, he went back to his previous culture when he went back to his own country. Regardless of societys views of their union, Janie denies all their criticism and lives happily. }
Generally, yes; though individuals prioritize fitting in to varying degrees, virtually everyone who interacts with society conforms to it in some way. This can be seen in our modern society, where there are ongoing debates . Conformity is a universal feature across societies. Regarding personality, psychologists who focus on human individuality look into the explanations and processes of patterns of behavior and experience. Groupthink refers to a specific kind of dysfunctional decision-making in which a group of well-intentioned people make irrational decisions. The story highlights the dangers of trying to force equality by limiting the abilities of those who excel in various areas. I agree with the point that was made in the video about conformity that occur in the American education system. This type of social influence was first studied by Arthur Jenness(1932) who asked research participants to individually estimate how many beans does a bottle contain. Presentation Transcript. But to fix the problems and to serve the students we must first have a vision of what good education is (Ravitvch). On the other. Some are numerical and scientific geniuses, while others have an enviable passionate way with words. In time, however, the individual's underlying beliefs and attitudes may begin to shift as the opinions and behaviors of the group become ingrained and automatic. When group members conceal critical information from each other in order not to rock the boat, or are willing to deny the evidence of their own senses, the group is at risk of groupthink or extreme polarization. In this case, compliance is also both public and private. The educational system is flawed and it does not prepare students to become successful adults.
Press Telegram: 20 Years Pass Since Long Beach Unifieds Historic School Uniform Policy. In my opinion, they educated us on things that our time in school did not. Can your breakfast cereal make you sick?
Individuality Vs Conformity - 524 Words | Internet Public Library Restatement of Thesis: Summary of Main Points (Three Reasons): The school day should begin later so students behavior/habits can improve, students can succeed in school and students can get the proper amount of sleep needed. This may sound like an outlandish problem, but this is what the average teenager goes through. However, conformity is not just acting as other people act, it is also being affected by how they act. Schools should adopt a more individualistic approach towards the classes students must take, and less of one concerned solely on test performance, because it would benefit students upon graduation by allowing them to pursue studies that interest them, and also benefit the school, John Taylor Gatto, a former school teacher, of Harpers Magazine, wrote We have been taught (that is, schooled) in this country to think of success as synonymous with, or at least dependent upon, schooling (Gatto). Jean Brown is a Registered Psychologist, licensed professional teacher, and a freelance academic and creative writer. School uniforms have long been common in parochial schools, but a number of public schools also have uniform standards. During school, students follow rigid schedules and high . Schools need to have more academic achievement appreciation rather than only appreciating the athletic students. Janie is not allowed to participate in any town events that are ruled as un-lady like by Jody. Not enough sleep isnt healthy. Prioritizing individuality in the schools allows students to be free of constraints, and to increase their want to learn through being able to differentiate and personalize their schedules. Conformity came from the Latin word conformare which means to form. Many schools are now organizing school day schedules to maximize instructional time and minimize non-instructional time, such as recess (Pellegrini & Bohn, 2005). Established group members may use a variety of tactics to persuade outsiders to conform, including praising, criticizing, bullying, or modeling "correct" behavior. Conformity in schools plays a major role in fulfilling their tasks of educating the teens and preparing them for the world outside the walls of school building. Categorized under Miscellaneous,Psychology | Difference Between Conformity and Individuality. Sometimes well-intentioned people don't act ethically. View on SAGE Save to Library Create Alert Schools should start later to prevent emotional disorders, depression, and anxiety from being sleep deprived. For example, a guest, who got invited to a birthday party, does not really like eating vegetables. While cooperating in a working society can help deflate uprising problems, getting used to changes, and completing work fast and easy, it can also make your personality go from special to bland. The alteration of the school schedule would also decrease productivity in students of all ages.
Conformity And Individuality In Schools - 627 Words | Studymode Students express their individualism with the habiliments they wear and the classes and the extra Co, In comparing a childs mind to an adults mind, a child has a much more difficult time comprehending and understanding multiple new topics in a day than an adult does. However, individuality without some amount of conformity is useless. So why is it that success is codependent with forced schooling? The pressure to buy the latest fashion can create stress on students, especially those who come from families without the financial means to keep up with classmates. Instead of focusing on students aptitudes and expanding on them, the Board of Education confines everyone into a box. They develop their position by effectively synthesizing* at least three of the sources. Most middle schoolers and high schoolers are sleep deprived because school starts too early. In comparison, psychological studies which are related with individuality include twin studies and adoption studies (nature vs nurture). About 87 percent of American high school students are chronically sleep deprived, according to a 2006 survey from the National Sleep Foundation. The three types of conformity according to Kelman are compliance (temporary behavioral change to receive a favorable reaction), identification (to be a member of a certain group but may stop when the individual leaves), and internalization (intrinsically motivated and relatively permanent behavioral change). Accordingly, by asking students to remain in classes for an extra two hours a day, school systems are requesting more devotion from teenagers who cannot focus for lengthy periods of time due to their developing brains. Individuality vs. Conformity: The Issue Behind School Uniforms P. Caruso Published 1 September 1996 Education NASSP Bulletin When we consider whether or not to implement a school uniform pot- icy, we need to understand the validity of each proponent's arguments. In evolutionary terms, going against ones group could be costly, and social cohesion was critical for the groups overall success. "Difference Between Conformity and Individuality." She argued that under these circumstances, an ideal student is the one, who is compliant, not overtly expressive, stays quiet in class and does not challenge the rules set by the teacher. Kokemuller has additional professional experience in marketing, retail and small business. Conformity motivated by deference to authority or fear of punishment is likely to be harmful.
Individuality vs. Conformity: The Issue Behind School Uniforms Conformity is a type of social influence involving a change in belief or behavior in order to fit in with a group. What is a good education? +1 845 259 2974 (11 a.m to 7 p.m CST). Schools often set early start times like 7:50 am. A desire for social harmony is another major driver of conformity. Everyone involved in our life has helped raise and teach us about almost everything as they all played a role in our lives. Analyzes how of 'individuality vs. conformity: the healthy middle?' states that there exists a delicate balance between complete individuality and complete conformity. America has come a long way in its education system. This will benefit my essay by forward explaining why school should start later in the morning and why doing this will be better for the students, Did you know that not enough sleep for teens can lead to poor organization, poor time-management skills, and can make them impulsive? However, conformity that protects the overall well-being of the groupmutually deciding to respect private property, for instancecan help societies succeed. Normative conformity refers to the shifting of behaviors and beliefs resulting from this information gathering. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail, Written by : gene Brown. Students with a passion in writing and reading should be allowed to take more classes to pursue their interests and help further them after graduation, instead of having them sit through math and science courses from which they will gain to practical or usable knowledge. Individuality refers to the quality that distinguishes a person from others. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. Conformity is the compliance with group norms or laws. Their prose demonstrates a consistent and updated on 2021, September 17, Difference Between Similar Terms and Objects. on September 30, 2022 in Understanding Hypnosis. A study has proven that lack of sleep will affect a teenagers life in a negative way, Overtime, not obtaining enough sleep can hurt students healthy, safety, social life, and school career. (National Sleep foundation 1) Due to teenagers naturally not being able to fall asleep till later in the night and forcing students to wake up severely early in the morning for school, they are exhausted. endstream
endobj
77 0 obj
<. Conformity in schools plays a major role in fulfilling their tasks of educating the teens and preparing them for the world outside the walls of school building. The underlying foundations of the issue incorporate poor teenager rest propensities that don 't take into account enough hours of value rest; rushed calendars with afterschool , activities and jobs, homework hours and family commitments; and a conflict between societal requests, for example, early school begin times , and natural changes that put most teens on a later rest wake clock. Though data is limited, some studies suggest the propensity for student violence is mitigated with conservative uniform policies because they remove some of the social and economic barriers between students. Students need to take less standardized tests. Individuality vs. Conformity: The Issue Behind School Uniforms Peter Caruso View all authors and affiliations Volume 80, Issue 581 https://doi.org/10.1177/019263659608058121 Get access Abstract When we consider whether or not to implement a school uniform pot- icy, we need to understand the validity of each proponent's arguments. Conformity should be enforced only to the point where it isnt affecting students mental and physical health due to loss of sleep, increases sociability, and teaches responsibility and independence. Cite The SAT, taken in the eleventh and twelfth grades, are the culmination of all the standardized tests students have taken in their kindergarten through twelfth grade academic careers. On the outside, Janie is restricted to the general store or the house, but in those times she would constantly question why she was not able to behave like a man. A shift in the conformity versus individuality attitude concerning mandatory classes and curriculum would cause several benefits to both students and schools. If she were to fill her roles as a woman she would not have married the third time and would have lived with how her life currently was. Conformity is the tendency for an individual to align their attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors with those of the people around them.
Conformity Vs Individuality Gre Essay | Best Writing Service Conformity is typically defined as the expectation of employees to adapt to company policies and standards and use traditional business practices to complete job functions. In this forum I will be discussing the quote from Mark Twian, "I have never let my schooling interfere with my education". Conformity is a universal feature across societies, leading researchers to suspect that it gave us an evolutionary advantage. The current school start time is unacceptable when thought about logically, and we must make the changes to have school start at a later time. Regardless of its form, it can be a powerful forceable to change how large groups behave, to start or end conflicts, and much more. This may manifest in their appearance, behavior, or the social norms they choose to follow. When conformity occurs because of fear, concern for ones social standing, or has dangerous consequences, it may be seen as negative. textbook as, A social institution that transmits attitudes, knowledge, beliefs, values, norms, and skills to its members through formal systematic training. Yet despite the many essential benefits that education offers, only 34% of Americans have a lot of confidence in our public schools.. http://www.differencebetween.net/miscellaneous/difference-between-conformity-and-individuality/. The following are the three types of conformity according to Kelman: It is a temporary behavior change since the compliance stops when there is no group pressure. How can overscheduled teenagers attend sports practice or club meetings, finish all of their homework, and perform any family or job obligations in such a short period of time? The 2 Most Psychologically Incisive Films of 2022, The Surprising Role of Empathy in Traumatic Bonding. To complete the matter further, the excision of Fridays from the school schedule would also cause teenagers to lose precious hours of sleep. The constant ringing of bells, lectures, bellwork, classwork, homework, each a daily practice throughout the school year. 76 0 obj
<>
endobj
Danes understand that wealth and happiness are public as well as personal matters. Waking up early affects teenagers social life, mentality, physical being, and academic career. This type of outlook is what gives conformity a negative reputation.
Individual Freedom vs. Forced Equality | by Erman Akdogan | Predict But, as I explained to the January 6th Select Committee, psychological factors help explain the insurrection. If one of the authors were instructors in one of my unnecessary classes they probably would make comments that Im weak minded or not genius. The amount of interest in education and acceptance of individuality is soon lost after finishing this system. Like Gutting said colleges sometimes give unnecessary courses, so it can be hard to be interested in something that in no way relates to your major. In most cases what school therapist diagnoses as attention deficient disorder, are no more than normal, hyperactive teens who are trying to express their individuality. The fairness of teaching students knowledge they will most likely never use for anything other than to pass a standardized test should called into question and evaluated. They need to be more motivated to go to school. A society needs people who are willing to draw their own conclusions in order to improve their life as well as those who live in the community. But what if that's just a bunch of stuffing? And why do we do things we dont really want to do? hbbd``b`f@1> }@B`"@& } ){1012H9q' {X
9
Even one voice of dissent can dampen a collective urge to conform to harmful behaviors. In practice. vertical-align: middle;
But if we start a littler later, will be way healthier and more educated, and simply have a better attitude. 2020 Leaf Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Media, All Rights Reserved.
Though it's often derided, conformity isn't necessarily a malevolent force. Students have thus neglected their education because of false expectations which are promoted along with unsatisfactory educators. It is matching ones behaviors to the majoritys expectations or the compliance with group norms or laws. Individuality And Conformity In Education Though individuality is important to the growth of public school attendees, it must also be balanced by social pressure. 2). Obediently, with their heads down, students are taught to become successful executives and agreeable members of society. As both the standards of school work and stress levels of students rise, the American school system remains unaltered, unchanged, and unaffected for over a hundred years. Essays earning a score of 8 effectively argue the extent to which schools should support individuality or conformity. Americas high schools are in desperate need of help. There are many reasons why students shouldnt have homework, during this essay people will learn why having homework isnt helping the student, except making things more difficult for them. Groupthink is often, but not always, spurred by a desire to conform. According to Harvard social psychologist Herbert Kelman, compliance is the outward appearance of conformity, regardless of whether or not ones internal beliefs have changed. This could easily be fixed by reformatting the school day. It should be a place of expressing ourselves freely in a learning environment without having to worry about what we wear as an interfering issue. Yesif you believe it can. We all know Thanksgiving is a colonialist holiday rooted in the genocide of Native Americans.
School Uniforms: Conformity vs. Creativity | ParentMap 83 FEATURES Individuality vs. Conformity: The Issue Behind School Uniforms By Peter Caruso Peter Caruso is a junior high school English teacher in Mesa, Ariz.
The fact that the school system cares more about the student dress code than their education is an issue in itself.
This can also affect many other things such as higher taxes, for more buses.
Individuality vs. Conformity: The Issue Behind School Uniforms One of these things is to fit in (par. Now, what are the goals of a true education? There are many flaws in the order of education, which causes students to worry more about satisfying others with test scores and academics rather than actually preparing them for the real world. Coming home after a long day of school, then having responsibilities to do at home, not to mention some students have after school activities which take up around 2 hours if not more. Meanwhile, the best things is to be focus in school so you can have a good career. E`#:#68R G'h 'NZ@OTRM`Lfe"9Q{UX5]tK#eL6 U@1|em+^Irx1(Bz^4cTBhqD4S_a! Conformity is typically motivated by a person's identification with a specific group.